A cabin crew Assessment Day or final interview can be incredibly daunting, and nerves are an inevitable part of the experience. But some of the coping mechanisms that many candidates rely on to get them through the day could be quietly wrecking their chances of being shortlisted.
First Impressions Form Fast
CareerBuilder and the Harris Poll surveyed over 1,000 hiring managers and HR professionals about what actually shapes their decision in an interview. Just under half, 49 percent, said they know within the first five minutes whether a candidate is a good fit for the role.
That means a large chunk of the interview is spent confirming a decision that’s already half made. Make no mistake, your answers still matter a huge amount, but your body language in those opening minutes is doing more work than most candidates realise.
The Body Language Mistakes That Cost Candidates the Job
The same survey asked hiring managers which body language mistakes stood out most. Here’s what they said, ranked by how often it came up:
Failing to make eye contact (68%). This is the single biggest one, by a wide margin. Eye contact signals that you’re engaged and being straight with the person you’re talking to. You don’t need to hold an unbroken stare. Make eye contact when you first meet the recruiter and hold it for a second or two, then keep returning to it naturally as you speak.
Top Tip: If direct eye contact makes you uncomfortable, look at a point just above the recruiter’s eyeline. It reads the same way from the other side of the table.
Not smiling (38%). A final interview is a serious moment, but showing none of your personality is a mistake. The recruiter is very likely nervous too, whether you’d guess it or not, and a genuine smile puts everyone at ease.
Two moments matter most: when you first meet the recruiter, and again when you’re leaving. This is your opportunity to flash a warm and genuine smile that will really resonate with the recruiter. Don’t worry, you don’t have to be grinning from ear-to-ear for the whole interview. Some questions deserve a more serious expression, and that’s fine. Let your face reflect the moment rather than holding one fixed expression the whole way through.
Playing with something on the table (36%). A pen, a hair band, anything. Put it down and leave it there. It’s a small thing, but it tells the recruiter your attention isn’t fully on the conversation, and it’s distracting for them even if they don’t say so.
Whatever you do, make sure your phone is nowhere in sight of the recruiter. Turn it off and put it in your bag before you even meet them.
Fidgeting (32%), crossed arms (31%), and poor posture (31%). These three tend to combine together, and they come across as a lack of confidence or engagement. When you sit down, find a position and commit to it for the whole interview: face the recruiter directly, feet flat on the floor, legs uncrossed, shoulders back, hands resting flat on the table or in your lap rather than clasped together. Getting into this position takes a bit of practice, especially when you’re nervous, so run through it a few times before the day itself.
Playing with your hair or touching your face (26%). This one often happens without the candidate noticing at all, since it’s a common response to stress. Keeping your hands in a fixed resting position, as above, is the simplest way to avoid it.
Handshake issues and too many hand gestures (13%). A weak, limp handshake reads as a lack of confidence. An overly firm one reads as trying too hard. Aim for a firm, brief handshake. Judge the moment on the grip of the recruiter.
Discreet hand gestures are fine in moderation. You want to show some energy and passion when you’re talking, but keep it controlled rather than expansive.
Worth Knowing
None of these mistakes are things that candidates do on purpose. They’re almost always a physical symptom of nerves. That’s exactly why practising your sitting position and your handshake in advance pays off, so that on the day, your body isn’t left to its own devices while your brain is focused entirely on the questions.
Quick Checklist
- Eye contact matters more than any other single body language cue. Make it early, and keep returning to it.
- Find a settled sitting position before the interview starts, and hold it throughout.
- Put anything in your hands down. Nothing on the table but what’s needed.
- A natural smile puts both you and the recruiter at ease.
- Practise your handshake and your posture in advance. Nerves make these things harder to control in the moment, not easier.
This page is part of our Interview Preparation Hub, covering everything from competency questions to the final interview itself. If you're getting ready for interview, here's where to go next.
